Cynicism

I often come across comments in blogs, not only my own but also in those of others. The word cynical so often comes into my mind, as synonymous as the attitude of those who are jaded, generally mistrust the integrity or good motives of other people. The cynic, always assuming the worst, is systematically sceptical, pessimistic and scornful – and sees others as motivated by self-interest.

Where does this word cynicism come from? There is an article on Wikipedia which shows cynicism as a school of ancient Greek philosophy. The original meaning is surprisingly different from the way we use the word to describe a scathing and negative attitude to life. The Greek Cynics saw virtue in a simple and unconventional life, and they were actually quite close to the Stoics. It perhaps became a basis of monastic life in Christianity from about the fifth century.

They were indifferent to what others would say about them in their eccentricities. They had no shame. In the Roman world, cynicism was held in disdain by Cicero, who saw it as being opposed to modesty. I would quite easily see the hippies and other anti-socials of the 1960’s as modern cynics if we follow this idea of simplicity and the rejection of social convention. Some historians wonder if Jesus was influenced by cynicism, but most scholars doubt this and see the Jewish prophetic tradition as of much greater importance.

I wonder what gave rise to the change of meaning from the cynic being some kind of hippy to being someone who disbelieved in altruism. Oscar Wilde defined a cynic as one who knows the price of everything and the value of nothing.

I have the impression that cynicism in this modern meaning of the word is one of our main obstacles to spiritual growth. In this morning’s Gospel, Christ says that if we do not become as a little child, we cannot enter the kingdom of heaven. Children are innocent, trusting, and above all, capable of the sense of awe and wonder. Cynics are jaded, have lost innocence and the sense of the wonderful and transcendent. It is of no wonder that they only see evil, self-interest and a trap in everything.

Cynicism is the opposite of prophecy. It is intellectual sloth and paralyses the spirit. The only way out of it, like all spiritual sicknesses, is prayer and conversion. Those of us who suffer from cynicism need to rediscover natural and man-made beauty, and discover altruism where it is to be found. Perhaps we would ourselves become more altruistic, and therefore closer to God.

If we remain cynics, we will lose the Faith and our happiness.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Cynicism

  1. Dear Father Anthony, I agree. I one for must watch being sarcastic from time to time. I have been trying to find a reason for my behaviour as such and I guess it reflects the utter disappointment I have in the TAC and some of the Clerics involved .When you show enthousiasm to return you are being rapped over the knuckles , when you get encouraging e-mails from abroad to get back on board and then hear nothing , yes , that is when the sarcasim sets in. Something to watch and pray about.
    Father Ed Bakker OPR

    • Please don’t get me wrong, Father. I have plenty to get cynical (modern meaning) about. It’s a question of what’s inside, our ability to bounce back from disappointment and failure – ours or of other people. I’m just trying to get something positive out and about. The TAC seems to have a future only in India, South Africa, the USA and Canada. I would give you the same advice as myself – carry on with “what we’ve got” and do the best we can.

  2. Dale's avatar Dale says:

    I think that we perhaps need to make a distinction between cynicism and bitterness. Personally, I find individuals who lack any sense of cynicism, especially when tempered with humour, to be incredibly tiresome after only a very short time (the type that bubble forth platitudes such as, “If can’t say anything nice about someone, don’t say anything etc., etc.”). Their incredibly “positive” outlook on life, and everything else, borders on the pathological. Not only are they boring, they tend to be fairly stupid as well; please be aware that this posting from a very cynical individual is simply my personal opinion.

Leave a reply to Fr Anthony Chadwick Cancel reply