Bloody Hell!

I have greatly appreciated the new posting of my brother in the priesthood Fr Jonathan Munn who has written The Eternity of the Other Place. I had a short discussion with him on Facebook, which inspired his article. We seemed to agree that the future of evil people after their death, or those who consciously rejected God, would be grim – to understate their predicament. Why should someone like Hitler or Ted Bundy be able to enjoy the same Presence of God as the saints and those who sought truth, beauty and goodness? I did express my doubts about the eternity of hell or whether it would be a transitory state where a soul might find salvation after some form of purification or purgation – as in the traditional notion of Purgatory

We are discussing concepts that lie beyond man’s experience in his “normal” state of consciousness, and all theological speculation is possible only by means of analogy and mythology. I am quite fascinated by the comparison of the foundational mythologies of Judaism, Christianity by extension of Judaism, Gnosticism and the ancient mystery religions insofar as we still know something about them. This would be the subject of a book of hundreds of pages and years of research. This is merely a quick article with the pressure of two translation orders to be delivered this afternoon.

Who is right? I can’t possibly know. Fr Jonathan has never hidden his affinity with scholastic theology, Thomism in particular on the basis of Greek realist metaphysics. He discusses the notion of eternity against time, time being the illusion in which we live in this present life, which seems real enough to us but is likely to be a kind of ‘hologram”. I know little about some of the mind-bending science offered for our consideration, but I am more or less sure that reality as portrayed by scholastic theology and Platonic / Aristotelian metaphysics is partial and a narrow view. His fundamental argument is that hell is as unending / eternal / everlasting / you name it as the happiness of the blessed in heaven.

On the assumption that our souls are not merely products of chemical reactions in the brain to be annihilated at the time of bodily death, these conventional notions are based on biblical and traditional analogies and images. The caricature of hell is the medieval torture chamber and the inside of active volcanoes, and that of heaven is a load of angels with wings sitting on clouds and strumming harps. That is the way the human mind works. Profound truths are not for the vulgar, and there has always been a distinction between religion for the masses and that of contemplatives.

Hell has been a great way to control the masses and keep them in line with the Church, paying their tithes and doing the right thing. It is the ultimate Thought Police. Orwell invented nothing – he just modernised it. Fiery pulpit-bashing preachers found it very effective at one time, and I have a wonderful Marcel Pagnol film of Alphonse Daudet’s Curé de Cugugnan. I hope your French is good enough to appreciate this amazing piece of writing. It will have to be, since this is not Parisian French, but the accent of Provence and Marseilles.

This way of communicating the disadvantages of refusing to be a Christian and take sin seriously has definitely lost its clout. The terrifying mystery of death and our existential questions remains.

I have myself written on various views of the afterlife on offer. Many mediums and seers are charlatans, and we can be seriously misled. Caveat emptor – buyer beware. Possibilities range from reincarnation to annihilation. There are too many stories of ghosts and stranded souls for them all to be illusions or fables. We now have theories of a multiverse and different possibilities of existence all at the same “time” but at different “frequencies”. Where I am conscious of myself, I am living in one world. In another I might be hanging on the gallows for my crimes, or an aristocrat or a priest or an explorer. Who knows?

Most traditions know of the notion of karma – justice for goodness and for sin as effect follows cause. Prayer and asceticism are means whereby the soul seeks to work his way out of the determinism of karma to a higher reality. In the distinction between Purgatory and Hell, two related analogies, where is the dividing line?

The prospect of death is the great leveller. We all face it sooner or later. However, we are also concerned for the present life and our existential questions. Bernard Moitessier spoke of continuing his voyage rather than completing the race, to “save his soul”. Salvation is something that begins in this life, as does damnation in the case of those “psychopath” people without conscience or empathy, those without remorse. In some ways, the world in which we live now is a place of purgation and separation from God, even though great beauty and life is also found. Origen is said to have suggested (I don’t have the exact quote to hand) that our world was the highest plane of hell, and that even Satan would find redemption were he to repent of his sins.

Was Origen right? I don’t know. Certainly his analogies were as imperfect as anyone else’s.

What is time and what is eternity. Is the hell of the damned totally without hope, or is it a state where justice will be served, but hope (however remote) is still possible. The laws of some countries impose life imprisonment without parole as an alternative to capital punishment, which is the ultimate vindictive punishment, assuming the absolute irreformability of the convict. In such wise, the damned soul already enters his own hell on this earth. Is it right for man to impose such a sentence? Perhaps. Perhaps not.

I tend towards an notion of reality being created by the idea. Our own mind can make a heaven (a great work of art or a piece of music for example) or a hell (the regime of Hitler, Stalin and the others in history).  John Milton said in Paradise Lost:

The mind is its own place and in itself, can make a Heaven of Hell, a Hell of Heaven.

Whilst remaining an orthodox Christian, I am aware of the limits of our imperfect analogies and appreciate the comparative approach, including the insights of modern science and other religions and philosophies. This side of the Veil, we will understand but precious little. St Paul used the expression “Though a glass darkly but then face to face”. The best we can do is to live by love, by prayer, by knowledge and devotion to God as a Trinity of Persons but also the All, to continue our perilous voyage like the ship at sea with faith, hope and love.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | 16 Comments

Wachet auf!

The same theme keeps coming back into my mind as I live some very special moments in my life. I have deliberately chosen the title that reminds us of the Bach cantata to which I linked a week ago, Wachet auf, ruft uns die Stimme (Wake up, the voice calls us). We are exhorted to wake up. In which way and from what kind of sleep? Clearly it doesn’t mean the moment at 6 am (or whatever time) when the alarm clock goes off and we climb bleary-eyed out of bed to make coffee and think about the day ahead. It is a much deeper meaning of sleep and waking.

It is an analogy taking from our daily cycle of sleeping and awakening. Sleeping is something we find very pleasant, especially if we are in a warm bed with familiar things around us. Sleep is also essential for life. We return in a way to our mother’s womb, unconsciousness and oblivion, the suspension of all the concerns and worries we have. It is also a “little death” as the office of Compline attests in the psalms, the hymn and final prayer. There is another meaning of sleep, the obliviousness of the realities of our lives and what really needs to be done. Sleep, both real and our intended analogy, are lower states of consciousness. Here are a few lovely lines of John Keats I set to music a couple of years ago:

What, but thee Sleep? Soft closer of our eyes!
Low murmurer of tender lullabies!
Light hoverer around our happy pillows!
Wreather of poppy buds, and weeping willows!
Silent entangler of a beauty’s tresses!
Most happy listener! when the morning blesses
Thee for enlivening all the cheerful eyes
That glance so brightly at the new sun-rise.

The kind of awakening I want to describe is that search for enlightenment, to which a few of us aspire, the highest level of consciousness. There are many states of consciousness, from sleep to drunkenness, our ordinary consciousness of getting that cup of coffee and feeling more human, the effect of psychedelics and higher states of mysticism (whether they can be attributed to God or extraordinary functions of the brain). Sometimes, we experience that sense of oneness with the All like the sailor at sea or Nietzsche’s titan Ubermensch walking the Alps like in the opening of a more recent Frankenstein film. The lone man in his ugliness and suffering in the snow is a powerful archetype.

I have been through a few weeks of extreme stress due to marriage issues, and I have wondered whether I should deal with this as an illness or the vector of a new understanding. Stress, as a doctor will tell us, is a reaction to danger. It is perfectly natural. The adrenalin rises when we are driving a car and an accident situation arises. We jam on the brakes and swerve to avoid the collision, and the worst is avoided (hopefully). For a few moments, we are overcome by a tingling sensation in our whole bodies, an extreme wakefulness, exactly what caused the reflex to slow the car without thinking about it or taking a conscious decision about what to do. This is stress at its most positive. In more emotional situations of life like in marriage or at work, for example, the process is slower than a near accident on the road, and it lasts for longer. Medicine offers various remedies against depression and stress, but are we as well equipped to do something about what is poisoning our lives? Personally, I chose to live with the stress and use it to find a new level of understanding. I refuse the drugs and I know I will be the stronger for it.

Waking up can be the “aha!” moment, when the electric bulb lights up or whichever analogy you choose. Occasionally, we experience something beyond ordinary awareness, an inspiration. The fiddle-string nerves can bring us to seek to transcend the poison, leave hatred and bitterness behind, close the door and find a new world. Here I am reminded of the scene in the film Amadeus, when Mozart’s wife and mother-in-law have an argument. Meanwhile, Mozart quietly goes into his study and continues to work on a composition. It often happens to a man under pressure from feminine emotions – he withdraws into contemplative solitude and enters a different level. Why do men and women have to be so different emotionally and spiritually? We should be complementary, but we are not.

I was extremely struck by the saying of Bernard Moitessier – C’est là, dans l’immense désert de l’Océan Austral, que je sens pleinement à quel point l’homme est à la fois un atome et un Dieu. This was for him an epiphany moment, an experience of God and the All. These past two weeks, I have not been to sea, but practically shut-in at home with a morose wife in the other bedroom. The only escape available to me was the imagination, by which everything is possible. Monastics often tell us that the imagination can lead us into danger, become an addictive drug, but it is also the key to creativity. It takes time for us to know where we are going, and I have that nagging sense of incompleteness. This is something we have to accept, for the process is ongoing. We remember the words of Jesus, “Ye are gods; and all of you are children of the most High“.

Other concepts of “waking up” are found in the eastern religions, in the practice of Yoga (when done properly). I have not had this kind of experience, and we should indeed be careful not to ask for more than what is good for us.

Waking up is not the same as awareness. We are aware (or should be) of the environment when we drive a car, sail a boat or simply walk downstairs. If we are not, we will have an accident and perhaps even get killed. Clumsiness is a sign of health problems, or simply carelessness about everyday things. I find clumsy and careless people hard to tolerate, because I really do appreciate precision and thought given to everything.

Waking up is something in our deepest being. It seems to us incomplete throughout life, even if it began with some inspiration. It is life-changing and we understand life totally differently. It is not something we can buy or learn during a crash course and get an instant “turn-on” (I don’t mean this in a sexual meaning). This awakening becomes our life vocation whether we are Christians, Buddhists or people who are alienated from any conventional religious tradition but yet seek beyond the noise, apologetics and marketing of those who are desperate to keep their institutions from crumbling financially. However, the awakening is gradual and frustratingly slow.

Our pilgrimages to enlightenment are so diverse, according to our different talents and vocations. In searching for ideas and answers to questions about change and vocation on Google, I discovered the notion of metanoia, the Greek word for change or transformation of mind. The word is used in Christianity to mean conversion, the process of a person turning from his past life to becoming a Christian. The prime example we find is St Paul, the persecutor of Christians falling off his horse, becoming blind and undergoing the transformation that would lead to his Baptism and becoming an Apostle. Psychologists like Jung used the word much more generally in the lives of people. There comes a point of life when we think and understand in a new way. We see a deeper meaning in life, and decisions we made in the past seem so superficial and immature. The “mid-life” crisis is often a sign of this metanoia. Priests leave the priesthood and get married, and formerly married men embrace the solitary life, but not always.

Waking up means emerging from the clouds into clear sunlight, as an aeroplane does after taking off. We learn that we have spent much of our life forcing pain down behind a British stiff upper lip, but it can be used in our regeneration, to become more compassionate to others who suffer more than we do. We need to discover what is within ourselves, especially all the conflicts behaving almost like autonomous personalities setting our aspirations to nought.

If we can arrive at an awaken state, we learn to focus on the essential. I am brought to think of composers like Mozart and Mendelssohn whose attention was precise and surgical. The result of their ability to concentrate and persevere is their abiding music. Our perception of things becomes more subtle and tolerant of imperfections outside ourselves. I do believe that such consciousness will bring us out of complexes and neuroses for which psychiatrists usually prescribe drugs. When the life of spirit is uppermost, one thing I have noticed is the ability to see the “big picture”, understand the things that are really going on in the world and often waved away as conspiracy theories. Indeed, some of the more absurd conspiracy theories are themselves signs of unconsciousness – and idiocy.

One of the most important things for me is being on the edge, challenging conventional thinking. This was a part of the “psychedelic” era when I was a young boy, which I remember as a strange paradox of individualism, silliness and a few true intuitions. Mainstream society emphasises power, money, status, control, efficiency, material growth and suchlike. These things never attracted me, and I was drawn to music, and in time to Catholic Christianity, priesthood and spiritual life.

I was always impressed with the words of Oscar Wilde as he languished in prison: You may realise it when I say that had I been released last May, as I tried to be, I would have left this place loathing it and every official in it with a bitterness of hatred that would have poisoned my life. This thought has been going through my mind these past few weeks. When we emerge from suffering, we must not do so with hatred, but with love for a higher ideal, something that is good and transcendent. Hatred only serves to poison the hater, and evil always flies back in the face of its perpetrator.

One thing this time has given me is patience, the ability not to allow my anxiety force me into rash judgements and actions. Good things come to those who can wait. Change for the better should not frighten us, if it is for the better. The Establishment likes everything to stay the same, the condition of stability. Change and spiritual growth are signs of life. When we are awake, we seek to be authentic, no masks or caricatures, no appearances or trappings beyond what we really are.

I have also had to think about attachments and addiction. It is not only to alcohol, drugs and cigarettes that we can become addicted, but also to things that appear to enhance our personality and fill in the void. One such addiction is that of the “dependent” person on another person, on his or her spouse or family, causing frustration and bitterness. It is the very worst basis of a relationship. X married Y because X needs Y affectively as a “drug” but hasn’t the slightest concern for the well-being, personality or feelings of Y. All Y can do is get out of the relationship however painful that will be, because otherwise he will die spiritually under the stifling toxicity.

Another thing I notice about “The Pit” is that people think nothing will happen unless they make it happen by their rational criteria. Nothing can be left to nature. The Romantic loves the seeming chaos of nature and randomness. The world has its rights independently of man. Being awaken brings us humility, tenderness, compassion and empathy. A couple of days ago when I was shopping, someone jumped ahead of me in the queue. His excuse was that he had left his items at the till and that he returned to the shelf to get something he had forgotten. He was ready for a hard battle to convince me, as if the normal response would be indignation and aggression. I felt no reason to challenge him, and simply let him take his place in front of me. It only cost me a couple of minutes. I feel the same way on the road when driving. Why are people so aggressive? The sense of entitlement one finds with many people is frightening. Christ’s way is humility, which is in truth realism about ourselves – we are both atoms and gods. I have often commented on the contrast between the ideology of strength and will, as found in twentieth-century totalitarianism, and the words and spirit of the Beatitudes – Blessed are the poor in spirit… When we see a handicapped child in a wheelchair or a man with half his face eaten away by cancer, what is our reaction? Should they be euthanised or seen as little angels of God whose spirits are already in the same heaven as Lazarus? Christianity’s weakness becomes its strength.

Waking up is the cure to all our ills, not anti-depressants and anti-anxiety pills. I refuse to take either, but rather let the frayed nerves do the waking – that’s what they are for. Unfortunately, waking up is not for everyone. Those with narcissistic and toxic personalities do not have the real basis of self to do this work. The inner reality of a bad personality is the void, the absence of humanity, which is a terrifying indictment for any human being. Was Calvin right? Are some intrinsically devoid of grace and made for damnation? I find that difficult to believe, but such beings obviously exist.

Another idea goes round, which is difficult to challenge with any credibility, the imprisoning effect of some religious ideologies. One purpose of this blog is to expose them so that we can keep and cherish the baby whilst changing the bathwater. Those who are very extroverted are dependent on the approval of others and follow fashions in clothing and consumer habits. “Groupthink” is something really nasty. We would prefer to believe it didn’t exist – but it does and is all around us.

The liturgical year begins with Advent, which is both a moment of awakening and waiting, because knowledge and consciousness only come progressively – just like over centuries with the Jewish people and the Gentiles and adepts of the mystery religions. Waking up is an experience of humanity over the centuries and the decades of our own lives.

In this little piece, I have particularly reflected on the idea of waking up at an individual or personal level. There is also the question of our whole world and humanity. A part of our vocation is get as many people as possible to understand the absurdity of our political and economic system and the suffering it causes through perpetual warfare and support of Islamic terrorism. That might be a vocation for some, and for others among us, we are drawn to the vocation of “white martyrdom”, the call of the cloister or the solitary’s little house of prayer.

I don’t think any of us can really be self-aware of being “awaken”. I have the impression of being conscious of something that can no longer be buried underground or covered up, forgotten or anaesthetised. I have the impression of a long learning curve that will cost me dearly, but yet lead me to a sense of meaning and direction in this absurd life. I wish my readers a similar discovery this Advent and the years and decades during which we wait for God and the dawning Redemption.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

The Important Things

I have been through a time of sadness and anxiety, which I have shared with my father and my Bishop. Discretion demands that I should not give any details in this public blog, but rather to seek positive meanings in these moments. Work has kept me housebound for the last month or so with only occasional outings in the car for necessary things like shopping.

It is at times like this that we ask the same question of what it all means. How do I relate to the Parable of the Talents? The two servants who were entrusted respectively with five and two units of money doubled their lord’s investment. The one who hid the talent and did not invest it judged himself out of his own mouth. It is one of the most terrifying utterances of Christ recorded in the Gospels. However, clearly, it does not support the “work ethic” by which people are “worth their money”. Christ also preached the Beatitudes in favour of the poor and suffering, the so-called “losers”. We now talk of talents as things we are made to do. Bach, Mozart, Mendelssohn and Beethoven were made to be composers and were prodigious in their genius. It was the same with artists, poets, writers and also with scientists, doctors, lawyers, great statesmen and benefactors of mankind. There are also the hidden talents of those whose vocations were not of this world. These are the monks, hermits and mystics – but also explorers, sailors and astronauts.

I have been reading a little more about Bernard Moitessier, about whom I have already written in my blog. His monastic desert was the sea, the great Southern Ocean with its wild climate and monstrous waves that daunt the greatest ships that have sailed them. One of his books was The Long Way, which I intend shortly to buy and read. The web page BERNARD MOITESSIER: Sailing Mysticism and The Long Way gives the gist of what such radical isolation does to a man. He either goes mad as did Donald Crowhurst (see Temptation on the High Seas), his competitor in the Golden Globe, or he discovers a whole new level of oneness with the One and the All. Moitessier apparently did not particularly identify with any particular religion. Like many of his generation, the tendency was to select notions from the eastern religions and combine them with New Age and pantheism. I am given to believe that the actual experience of purgation would have brought him beyond many of the superficialities of commercialised mysticism of the 1960’s.

It would seem that Moitessier did not weigh anchor and put to sea in order to have a spiritual experience, but it came about over the months and years he spent at sea. As I have read in Joshua Slocum’s story, Moitessier’s narrative is quite prosaic. The combination of the boat and the sea is a complex piece of mechanism which requires constant attention and understanding of its principles. There isn’t much time to have one’s head in the clouds! Being alone on a boat takes away all our inhibitions that society imposes on us, and which we feel duty-bound to respect. There are no conventions. It all depends on the person setting sail: the voyage leads to insanity or illumination. I have read as much of men joining the Carthusians and facing themselves in solitude. What kind of guys are we to face ourselves? We will quickly discover the meaning of sin and redemption!

Moitessier practiced Yoga, and there is a photo of him in the lotus position for meditation.

I have never tried it myself. Physically, it must be torture to cross your legs like that! It takes a high degree of physical fitness and discipline of mind. I admire people who do Yoga, because there must be great benefits from it as from any spiritual discipline of any tradition. Thomas Merton sought riches from the east to enrich western monastic spirituality. Many judged him for syncretism and infidelity to the truth of Christianity. Not I. We need to find what is good everywhere since Christ’s mission is universal and the full realisation of all archetypes.

He found peace at sea like nowhere else. He sensed it as a living creature, with the world and the entire universe. The sea sings and communicates with us. I have had something of this experience whilst sailing a ten-foot dinghy from Loctudy to the Glénans archipelago in southern Brittany, though my voyage only lasted a few hours (a bit longer on the way back in a weakening wind). What Moitessier experienced on the Southern Ocean can only be imagined! The sea brings us to absolute humility, yet enables us to discover the spark of divinity within us.

Sailing in these waters, if man is crushed by his feeling of insignificance, he is borne up and protected by that of his greatness. It is here, in the immense desert of the Southern Ocean, that I feel most strongly how much man is both atom and god.

I definitely feel the world to be alive, not merely an inanimate object to be exploited by man. I had something of the same experience at Triors Abbey in the early months of 1997, when I sought the first signs of spring, the sap returning to twigs on bushes, the first caterpillars that would become butterflies through that wonderful process of metamorphosis. There were also the smells of the earth as the frost thawed and the days became gradually longer. When the dawn could be seen through the church window as the monks sang the Benedictus at the end of Lauds, this was already a miracle.

I don’t have the boat or navigational skills to sail on blue water (usually defined as beyond six leagues from the coast), though I have my eyes on the various sites of boats for sale. It is not the time to aspire to anything beyond my present twelve-foot dinghy that sails along coastlines and requiring no more than a bearing compass, a Portland plotter and a chart. I do most of my inshore navigation by eye and intuition, and I am rarely far wrong in reckoning with currents and drift. I am at one with vast expanses of water and can confidently perceive their geometry and character as something alive. We all to some extent experience what Moitessier found.

Still, I have the persisting idea of a Hurley 22, a boat on the small side but with a stout hull and a long keel, used many decades ago for training new recruits in the Royal Navy. They can be found for as little as a couple of thousand pounds with everything in good condition. They have been known to cross the Atlantic and prove to be highly seaworthy vessels.

Psychologists often try to find a rational explanation, but often on the false premiss that the brain is the cause of consciousness, instead of consciousness being a “guest” of the brain but which can survive in some way as a “soul” or “spirit”. The “spontaneous religious sentiment” was known to Freud in those who found a bond with the world. The earth is truly a mother, something we experience at sea, walking in high mountains or what astronauts experience on seeing the earth from space. I do find it encouraging that science is ‘catching up” and discovering consciousness instead of dismissing it because it is not material.

I am a loner, something that is utterly incompatible with marriage, and this is something of my present search. As things are, it is important to live and love the little things of life, everything that is familiar at home, the sight of two wintered boats in the back yard, my chapel , the little routines of life and my priestly existence.

The important thing about this posting is to say that there is always light at the end of the tunnel, in spite of life’s crises and storms, there is always a way through, just like on a boat at sea. Perhaps one message from Moitessier, as from the hermit in his cell, is the gratuity of life. Purpose of life is not always utilitarian or even humanitarian. It can be simply a matter of taking the helm, sheeting in the sails and keeping an eye on the compass. At sea, we are at the same time gods and atoms.

To return to the Parable of the Talents, I don’t believe that Christ meant material things like investments and money, but something that the holy bishop, the nurse in Africa, the lone sailor and the hermit have in common. Our calling and our destiny are mysteries, even to ourselves, and many die with regrets as hospice nurses and chaplains often testify. We are all in need of Christ’s love and mercy that both transcend the law of Karma and tit-for-tat justice.

The boat may be laid up on hard standing as we rope-pullers call it, but we have Advent and all those wonderful prophecies of Isaiah to read in anticipation of the Mystery of Christ.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | 6 Comments

More Papal Bull

I invariably have other things to do when some new absurdity comes out of the Roman Catholic Church. The newest is that Pope Francis is being threatened by four Cardinal whistle-blowers over the issue of allowing civilly remarried divorcees to receive Communion.

In a former article, I mentioned this issue as being better dealt with as a matter of conscience in the confessional. Not all cases are the same. I have my own experience of marriage – and St Paul considered marriage as an option for those too weak for celibacy. Some people have been dealt a really raw deal in life, but that is between them and their parish priests and their local diocesan nullity tribunal. I don’t want to go into the question from the point of view of moral or sacramental theology, canon law or pastoral care of the faithful.

My attention was drawn to An FAQ for All Christians on Divorce, Pope Francis and the Bishops Questioning Him.

Q: How can the doctrine of papal infallibility survive this?

A: Fans of logic will note that it can’t. If Pope Francis continues on the course he has chosen, he will prove, empirically, that this teaching was never true in the first place.

Q: What will that mean for the First Vatican Council?

A: That council, and every other council the Catholic Church has held since the great Schism with the Orthodox in 1054, will be called into question. The Orthodox theory, that it was Rome which went off the rails back then, will start looking pretty persuasive. Last time I checked, making the case for that was not the Roman pontiff’s job.

So that is what is tickling the Jesuit Pope as he thinks about ripping off no fewer than four Cardinals’ hats, from men who have acted within the limits of canon law! It is all becoming abject nonsense.

We Anglican Catholics follow principles given in the Affirmation of St Louis. A few extracts:

We cannot decide what is truth, but rather (in obedience) ought to receive, accept, cherish, defend and teach what God has given us. The Church is created by God, and is beyond the ultimate control of man.

We repudiate all deviation of departure from the Faith, in whole or in part, and bear witness to these essential principles of evangelical Truth and apostolic Order:

The received Tradition of the Church and its teachings as set forth by “the ancient catholic bishops and doctors,” and especially as defined by the Seven Ecumenical Councils of the undivided Church, to the exclusion of all errors, ancient and modern.

We disclaim any right or competence to suppress, alter or amend any of the ancient Ecumenical Creeds and definitions of Faith, to set aside or depart from Holy Scripture, or to alter or deviate from the essential pre-requisites of any Sacrament.

There are many small Churches that came into being because authority and institution have been perverted and corrupted. This has always been the cause of schism and the reflex of surviving outside the system in small communities. We do this because we cannot call the whole Christian message nonsense as many have done. We try to go on. So do many good and devout Roman Catholics and people from other communities.

The internet has helped to bring about a new paradigm in politics. May the swamp be drained in Rome too!

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , | 9 Comments

Bach’s Cantata on Wachet auf ruft uns die Stimme

Quoted from the You Tube page:

Wachet auf, ruft uns die Stimme, BWV 140 (1731)

Boy Soprano: Alan Bergius
Tenor: Kurt Equiluz
Bass: Thomas Hampson
Chorus master: Gerhard Schmidt-Gaden
Tölzer Knabenchor
Conductor: Nikolaus Harnoncourt
Concentus musicus Wien

I. Chorus: Wachet auf, ruft uns die Stimme (Sleepers awake, the voice is calling us)
II. Recitative: Er kommt (He comes)
III. Aria (duet): Wann kommst du, mein Heil? (When will you come, my salvation?)
IV. Chorale: Zion hört die Wächter singen (Zion hears the watchmen singing)
V. Recitative: So geh herein zu mir (So come in with me)
VI. Aria (duet): Mein Freund ist mein! (My friend is mine!)
VII. Chorale: Gloria sei dir gesungen (May Gloria be sung to you)

A church cantata by German composer Johann Sebastian Bach (1685-1750), with the cantata chorale based on the Lutheran hymn “Wachet auf, ruft uns die Stimme” (“Sleepers awake, the voice is calling”) by Philipp Nicolai. The text is based on the Parable of the Ten Virgins in Matthew 25:1-13, the reading of which is scheduled for the 27th Sunday after Trinity in the Lutheran lectionary. This cantata was first performed in Leipzig on November 25, 1731. Bach later transcribed the fourth movement chorale for organ (BWV 645) and published it along with the Schübler Chorales.

English text:

I. (Chorus)

Wake ye maids! hard, strikes the hour,
The watchman calls high on the tower,
Awake, awake, Jerusalem.
Midnight strikes, hear, hear it sounding,
Loud cries the watch, with call resounding:
Where are ye, o wise virgins, where?
Good cheer, the Bridegroom come,
Arise and take your lamps!
Alleluja!
Ye maids beware:
The feast prepare,
So go ye forth to meet Him there.

II. Recitative:

He comes.
The Bridegroom comes!
And Zion’s daughter shall rejoice,
He hastens to her dwelling claiming
The maiden of his choice.
The Bridegroom comes; as is a roebuck,
Yea, like a lusty mountain roebuck,
Fleet and fair,
His marriage feast he bids you share.
Arise and take your lamps!
In eagerness to greet him;
Come! hasten, sally forth to meet him.

III. Aria (Duet)

[Soul] Come quickly, now come.
[Jesus] Yea quickly I come.
[Soul] We wait thee with lamps all alighted!
The doors open wide,
Come claim me my bride!
[Jesus] The doors open wide,
I claim me my bride.
[Soul] Come quickly!
[Jesus] Forever in rapture united

IV. Chorale

Zion hears the watchmen calling,
The Faithful hark with joy enthralling,
They rise and haste to greet their Lord.
See, He comes, the Lord victorious,
Almighty, noble, true and glorious,
In Heav’n supreme, on earth adored.
Come now, Thou Holy One,
The Lord Jehovah’s Son!
Alleluja!
We follow all
The joyful call
To join Him in the Banquet Hall!

V. Recitative

So come thou unto me,
My fair and chosen bride,
Thou whom I long to see
Forever by my side.
Within my heart of hearts
Art thou secure by ties that naught can sever,
Where I may cherish thee forever.
Forget, beloved, ev’ry care,
Away with pain and grief and sadness,
For better or for worse to share
Our lives in love and joy and gladness.

VI. Aria (Duet)

[Soul] Thy love is mine,
[Jesus] And I am thine!
[Both] True lovers ne’er are parted.
[Soul] Now I with thee, and thou with me.
[Jesus] In flow’ry field will wander,
[Both] In rapture united forever to be.

VII. Chorale

Gloria sing all our voices,
With Angels all mankind rejoices,
With harp and strings in sweetest tone.
Twelve bright Pearls adorn Thy Portals,
As Angels round Thy glorious Throne.
No ear has ever heard
The joy we know.
Our praises flow,
Eeo, eeo,
To God in dulci jubilo.

May this cantata and this new Advent wake us from our lack of consciousness, that we may be ready to be invited to the Throne of the divine Lamb.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | 4 Comments

Sarum Calendar 2017

Those of you who are interested in the Use of Sarum, or use it, can find the liturgical calendar on The Sarum Rite, a site run by Dr William Renwick, a Canadian professor of music. I quote his introduction to the calendar:

The Kalendar appearing here contains in the third column the information provided in the printed Sarum Kalendars such as that found at the front of the Breviarium 1531. In the fourth column appears the information found in the Pica which appear scattered throughout the Breviarium. Generally speaking the latter takes precedence over the former where they differ. This Kalendar is provided firstly as a guide to those who wish to follow the Sarum Liturgical Kalendar throughout the course of the year, and secondly for those who wish to gain an understanding of the nature of a typical Sarum or pre-Tridentine liturgical year. These Kalendars follow the Gregorian or Western calendar rather than the Julian calendar.

These calendars start from January 1st, not from the first Sunday of Advent. For this reason, if you don’t already have it, you need to start this new liturgical year from 27th November of the 2016 calendar.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , | 1 Comment

Happy Thanksgiving 2016!

To my American friends, a happy Thanksgiving to you all, and wishing peace and God’s blessing for your nation. May those who govern and lead it be inspired by God’s grace and a sense of justice – doing the right thing for the common good.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged | Leave a comment

Thoughts from the November Gloom

Naturally, the title of this posting only applies to those living in the northern hemisphere. The heavenly cycles go their way as predictably as a clock as it measures the cycles of time that mark our life and death in this world.

Since writing my previous post touching upon the miseries of those clinging to the Roman Catholic Church for some vestige of truth, security and authority, I find a whole tendency of articles. My friend JV has published Perspective during ecclesiastical twilight and Refugium Peccatorum. His feed of links gives Why I Cannot Be a Post-Evangelical, Post-Denominational, etc., Christian by an Orthodox priest in America. All three need to be read.

There is little to add to my previous reflections, but we all have short memories, suffer from cognitive dissonance and yearn for something more than the bleak reality we face in the local parish church near our homes where the priest and people continue in their ways of life. They seem so oblivious to anything outside what is most familiar, and we see that we are just about all the same. We have to be.

The internet to some extent has given us an illusory notion of the Church’s universality in a world where the massive majority of people are materialists or claim some other philosophy of life to justify their individuality and existence above the morass of humanity. Someone living in a city can wander in the streets and contemplate the spires and bell towers of the church buildings, witnesses of another era. For us in the country, the villages churches and wayside calvaries are still there, some lovingly tended by simple and devoted folk hoping and waiting for more spiritually enlightened times. Home in closer, and what we find in the church are generally signs of decay and death. The Platonic universal idea of a Church is expressed in something that is dying or already no longer exists in the place where we look for it.

In terms of the Church, many of us find ourselves in a situation like in the late 1790’s. The murderous tyranny of Robespierre is over, but even more forgotten is that age of light and reason from more frivolous days that has failed the innermost desires of us all. Already, last November, I posted Byron’s Darkness, a vision of the world destroyed by disease, something from outer space hitting the planet or some terrible human conflict. It is the Dies irae, the Eschaton we all fear and anticipate in these gloomy pre-Advent days.

We are all going to react in different ways. The mind of an idealist would project his desire on reality to bring about the dream, at least partially. I have moved far from my Thomist and metaphysically realist seminary days, and see hope in some of the flashes of information we get about quantum physics. Reality is a hologram, and it can in some way be changed by consciousness, information and energy. It all sounds crazy, but these discoveries and theories offer us a modern alternative to brute materialism.

The problem with most churches is that they have failed us. They leave thinking and profound people disappointed. Some churches are able to survive either by providing entertainment, some kind of social fulfilment for otherwise lonely souls or expressing ideologies that affirm egos and our base instincts. If Christianity is true, or if it has something to offer, then it is elsewhere from the decaying fish-heads of churches. This is no theme to write on. Churches have always been powerhouses of spirituality and prayer, or expressions of human sin and mediocrity.

Some of us are more privileged than others: living in a city where there is a church offering an uplifting liturgy and a sense of fellowship and prayer, having a car so as to be able to drive out to that monastery in the fields and attend the monks’ Office and Conventual Mass. I am a priest and have my own chapel, and am thus responsible to do my tiny bit for the canonical Church that confers my mission as a priest. There is only so much a man can do alone.

Many atheists criticise Christian and other “irrational” believers in terms of our seeking security in a hostile environment in which we have to compete against others just to break even. Claiming to be a member of the “right” church gives an illusion of being above the struggle for survival. Perhaps it becomes so for some, but not for all. We all have our demons in the closet, which would follow us even to the Pacific Islands or a skete in the rocks of the Isle of Patmos. Admittedly, being away from the bestial struggle, or what modern humanity calls the Rat Race, is more conducive to finding the Spirit within us.

We return to the so-called Benedict Option. It is within each of us and within the reach of us all – that is if it isn’t a fantasy of trappings, but a real life lived within and with complete sincerity. There was once a priest in our Diocese who aspired to monastic life. He put on a habit and called his home a priory. He then called himself a prior and fancied himself as a mitred abbot. The question was – Of what? Later, he turned to alcohol and joined another marginal church (or rather a group of bishops-of-nothing) and himself became a bishop of nothing. This illusion is so tragic and has to be a lesson for us all.

The real Benedict Option is invisible and unknown. It exists wherever someone opens an Office book, says Mass, lights a candle and prays, does something kind to someone in need, all the intimate little things written in the New Testament by people like St John. There is an ideal fuelled by our deepest desires and sense of God’s calling, and it has to live underground, in the catacombs allowing rays of light out into the world for those few who have ears to hear and eyes to see. It is so subtle and so simple.

But all that is blown away by pride and pretence to be something other than ourselves in our limitations and insignificance.

He hath put down the mighty from their seat : and hath exalted the humble and meek.

He hath filled the hungry with good things: and the rich he hath sent empty away.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , | 2 Comments

Oh dear! Prosciugare la Palude…

See The latest from Rome. When Benedict XVI abdicated, one intention of Pope Francis was in some way to “drain the swamp” in Rome, to coin the slogan now used by the Trump campaign / beginning of administration in America. Is Pope Francis hob-nobbing with globalists and the true “deplorables” of this world? I have the impression that not only has the Roman swamp not been drained, but is yet more murky. Eeek!

Cuius rex eius religio – if you get my meaning…

I am glad I am no longer a convert Roman Catholic. Just get on with life.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , | 40 Comments

Some Really Kooky Stuff

It appears that the Trump victory has brought some really odd stuff on the internet, one is a political ideology called Alt-Right (alternative right). I only heard about this term a few days ago and read various things about its opposition to globalism and other subjects presently discussed between the radical tendencies now coming out of the woodwork and the “smug” establishment conservatism.

All of a sudden, I find myself completely out of my depth with some very hard-core stuff coming from white supremacists in the US and even some form of vindication of aspects of Nazism. It is all very frightening. For the purpose of being informed, I found this in a Google search – Daily Stormer. Sturmabteilung? I do not endorse or approve this site but simply include it as an example for study. It all makes me very cold within. Trump seems quite supportive of Alex Jones, who makes me an Englishman laugh at his exaggerations and caricature of the enterprising American. David Icke is an Englishman, and is less vocal about the “shape-shifting alien reptiles”. I find myself drawn to some ideas expressed by these men, but the ideology taken as a whole seems both frightening and dangerous.

I am confident that the worst excesses will remain marginal, both in the USA and over here in Europe. I am one of the millions to be totally disenfranchised by mainstream politics and media, and now have to be so careful with the alternative as with a bomb in my hand or whatever.

We live in a time when we need to be open-minded to new information – but extremely critical and cautious, doing the best we can to verify things like multiculturalism, globalism and matters that seem to offend against Christian moral teaching. People get so steamed up about single-issues that the only healthy reaction is to disengage and study issues from different points of view. I got quite carried away last week, and I cannot help saying that many will come out of these changes disappointed.

Be sober and vigilant…

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged | 4 Comments