A Service of Nine Lessons and Carols

A Service of Nine Lessons and Carols

Hymn: Once in royal David’s city. English Hymnal no. 605

The Bidding Prayer

Organ: J.S. Bach, Durch Adams Fall ist ganz verderbt. BWV 637

Lesson 1

Organ: J.S. Bach, Es ist das Heil uns kommen her. BWV 638

Lesson 2

Organ: J.S. Bach, Vom Himmel hoch, da komm’ ich her. BWV 606

Lesson 3

Organ: J.S. Bach, Puer natus in Bethlehem. BWV 603

Lesson 4

Organ: J.S. Bach, Gelobet seist du, Jesu Christ. BWV 604

Lesson 5

Organ: J.S. Bach, Der Tag, der ist so freudenreich. BWV 605

Lesson 6

Organ: J.S. Bach, Vom Himmel kam der Engel Schaar. BWV 607

Lesson 7

Organ: J.S. Bach, Lobt Gott, ihr Christen, allzugleich. BWV 609

Lesson 8

Organ: J.S. Bach, Jesu, meine Freude. BWV 610

Lesson 9

Hymn: O come, all ye faithful. English Hymnal no. 28

Final Prayers and Blessing

Organ: J.S. Bach, In dulci jubilo BWV 729
Sigfrid Karg-Elert (1877-1933), Nun danket alle Gott, Op. 65

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged | Leave a comment

O Clavis David

O Key of David, and Sceptre of the house of Israel; who openest and no one shutteth, who shuttest and no one openeth: come and bring the prisoners out of the dungeon, from the prison those who sit in darkness and the shadow of death.

Charles Hubert Hastings Parry (1848-1918), Chorale prelude on St Mary

“O Lord turn not thy face from me
Who lie in woeful state.”

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged | Leave a comment

Fourth Sunday of Advent

We have the “Rejoice in the Lord alway” Epistle on this Sunday in the Use of Sarum, which might be a surprise to those who are used to the Roman rite. Which is right, Sarum or Rome? It needs a little study. St John the Baptist is the Vox clamantis in deserto – The voice of one crying in the wilderness. An English idiom for someone who expresses an idea or opinion that is not popular or that the individual is the sole person expressing that particular opinion with the suggestion that the opinion is then ignored. We need to be ourselves and not go with the crowd. Be bold, be original. Persevere with what you believe to be right.

Johannes Brahms (1833-1897), Mein Jesu, der du mich.

J.S. Bach (1685-1750), Nun freut euch, lieben Christus gmein, BWV 734a

Alec Rowley (1892-1958), Fantasia on Veni Emmanuel

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged | Leave a comment

And on it goes…

Adventures of the Scarlet Pimpernel - Volume 1 DVD (1955) - Television on - Alpha Video | OLDIES.com

There is a new article in Rorate Caeli about Pope Francis’ determination to force the traditionalist institutes to conform to the new liturgy or face canonical sanctions forcing them to close. Maybe I should take a nihilistic attitude and say that I don’t care. After all, I left that world in the mid 1990’s and joined the Continuing Anglican world by a long route.

Here is the article.

This article refers to Responses to certain provisions of the Apostolic Letter in the form of a “Motu Proprio” Traditionis Custodes issued by the Congregation for Divine Worship. This piece of writing provoked one of our own priests to suggest on Facebook that we could petition our Anglican Catholic Church bishops to prepare for the corporate reception for groups of Romans attached to traditional Roman Rite to enter the Anglican Catholic Church as a body of Roman Rite Anglicans. Perhaps to be called the Roman Ordinariate of St. Augustine of Canterbury. Someone good at Latin could write Romanorum coetibus. The idea sounds like a joke, but I am not sure that it was intended as one.

I know the conservative and traditionalist Roman Catholic world. For them, the delict of schism – leaving the RC Church to join another – is the very worst thing you can do. Say heretical things like denying the Trinity or the divinity of Christ is much less serious. You just recant and everything is made right. Commit a delict of schism – and you are finished. It brings perpetual irregularity to the reception or exercise of Orders. So you have to be rather sure. Normally some form of resistance is possible if canon law is not violated. This is the kind of stuff they taught us at Gricigliano.

Obviously, those institutes are not going to crawl and start using the Novus Ordo. There have been compromise situations involving Institute priests in France in parish ministry. Inevitably the priests suffered inner conflict and ended up by leaving the Institute and joining the diocese they were serving for the sake of their pastoral responsibilities. This kind of situation certainly has its parallel in the Church of England but with a little less rigidity. Join an Anglican jurisdiction? To French and other traditionalists, Anglicanism is Protestantism and they would not recognise our Orders.

There would be two possibilities for those for whom an act of schism would be absolute taboo. One is the solution of the Society of St Pius X: consecrate bishops and ordain priests outside canonical norms but without claiming to be a separate ecclesial entity. You claim a situation of necessity and emergency, and then you can invoke the principle of ἐπιείκεια, a canonical principle that a law can be broken to achieve a greater good. It is a concept in canon law that one would have difficulty finding in civil and penal law. On account of this reasoning, the Society of St Pius X has not been considered as formally schismatic like the Old Catholics of the Netherlands, Switzerland and Germany. Two possibilities? Yes, join the Society of St Pius X in the same way as several religious communities (Benedictines, Dominicans, Franciscans, etc.) have solidarised with them. That or do the same thing by finding a Roman Catholic bishop prepared to act exactly like Archbishop Lefebvre did – set up a quasi-canonical entity, one or several seminaries, mass-centres, schools, periodicals, etc. and ordain priests and consecrate bishops as needed to continue indefinitely independently from Rome.

Less scrupulous elements roped in bishops having suffered persecution or exile like Archbishop Pierre-Martin Ngô Đình Thục. This Archbishop was immediately discredited by his involvement with the sect of Palmar de Troya in 1976 and then with various groups of radical sedevacantists in France and the USA. A similar thing seems to be happening with Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò in a confusing story involving radical traditionalist elements in Italy. The Archbishop denies such influence, yet he expresses himself in a way that no Curial of diplomatic cleric would speak or write, including wild conspiracy theories and all kinds of other cranky stuff. Would any other Roman Catholic bishop consider taking such a gamble?

In the years before the Institute of Christ the King was established (1990), there were priests acting as “scarlet pimpernels” in Rome. The two most active were Fr Gilles Wach who was doing his doctorate and living at the Irish College and Fr Gregor Hesse, an Austrian priest working for Cardinal Alfons Stickler. The “ratline” was simple. Former SSPX seminarians or lay candidates for entering a seminary went to Rome to complete their studies at the Angelicum and live in one of the many pontifical colleges. They would keep quiet about their intentions, and at the right time, Fr Hesse or Fr Wach would find a diocesan bishop in Italy or some other part of the world willing to sign the proper papers to incardinate the cleric in question. Once the legality was satisfied, it was a simple matter to get the man ordained in Rome by a retired bishop or Cardinal. Many went through this route to the priesthood. They would then go on to independent ministries for traditionalist associations willing to pay their stipends. The 1980’s were a different time, because the Pope was John Paul II who was progressively favouring the traditionalists. Such arrangements would be rooted out in short order these days.

Remember, anything but commit the delict of schism or an ordination without some kind of canonical title. In my present state of life, I would imagine them setting up some kind of Old Roman Catholic church, except that Archbishop Arnold Harris Mathew made a complete mess of it because he trusted some very questionable elements who ruined the entire movement. The same thing would happen in the sedevacantist world and also in Continuing Anglicanism culminating in the conflicts between bishops in late 1997. With the passage of time, most of the main traditionalist groups stabilised and became quite institutionalised. What would now happen if the Fraternity of St Peter, the Institute of Christ the King and the various religious and monastic communities lost their canonical basis? Which Cardinal or bishop is ready to lay his reputation on the line to ensure their perennity? Which superior would be prepared to get an illicit consecration?

It all looks quite hopeless. Maybe Rome is going to lose its gamble, but they usually don’t. Pope Francis is obviously determined to finish off the “traditionalist problem”. As in our secular world, money and power trump law. Fr Barthe is a good canonist, but canonical arguments cannot take on such a formidable foe. Resist the unjust law? How?

The balance of power today is much more favourable to the traditional world than it seems, especially in France, where it will not let itself be taken over.

There is the possibility that diocesan bishops might resist and continue to ordain, confirm and to protect the communities under his oversight. To what extent can a local Bishop resist Rome and the national episcopal conference bureaucracy? It seems a tall order. Without bishops, the traditionalist institutes will go the way of the Petite Eglise or the Безпоповцы Old Believers in Russia – communities of laity without priests or Sacraments other than Baptism and Marriage.

What is going to happen? I would be happy to receive comments with suggestions.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , | 8 Comments

O Adonay and O Radix Jesse

I forgot to post yesterday’s O antiphon devotion, so it is here.

O Lord and Ruler of the house of Israel, who didst appear to Moses in a burning bush, and didst give him the law on Sinai: Come and deliver us with an outstretched arm.

J.S. Bach (1685-1750), Nun komm, der Heiden Heiland, BWV 699

And today’s, O Radix Jesse.

O Root of Jesse, who standest for an ensign to the peoples, at whom kings shall shut their mouths, and to whom the Gentiles shall pray: Come and deliver us, and do not delay.

Charles Hubert Hastings Parry (1848-1918), Chorale prelude on Christe, Redemptor Omnium.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Young Organists

This is Richard McWeigh, an English cathedral musician who is popularising organ music and a simple spirituality on YouTube. We are blessed by modern technology in giving us the Hauptwerk organ, recordings of each note and each stop of a pipe organ which we can play on a keyboard to get the authentic sound that surpasses the sound of electronic and digital organs. This makes it possible to play the organ at home. My own organ is a pipe organ, but it is very small. Thanks to Hauptwerk, Richard has a full cathedral organ in his house where he lives with his family. Do his neighbours like organ music? That is a good question determined by the soundproofing of his walls and windows!

He heard the complaint some years ago from an English cathedral organist that young people were no longer learning the organ and committing themselves to church music. It was a dying cause. Richard has proven him wrong and there are many young people learning the organ and setting up their own Hauptwerk instruments in their homes, using commercially available keyboards and pedalboards or using an old electronic organ console with the new technology.

Here is a recital of young musicians playing a pipe organ in a church or their Hauptwerk instruments. The youngest in only 12. I am deeply impressed by this love of music as I experienced at their age. Their dexterity and brilliance are impressive. Some will play in churches, and others will go on to be concert musicians. The love of music continues, wherever the wind may blow.

I have taken a certain amount of inspiration from Richard’s concept of “beauty in sound” and turning it to Christian witness. It has certainly given me a new dimension in my priestly ministry.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , | 1 Comment

O Sapientia 2021

I am doing a series of Advents devotions based on the great “O” antiphons from the Sarum Office.

O Wisdom, who didst issue out of the mouth of the most High, and dost reach from one end of the world to the other, mightily and sweetly ordering all things: Come and teach us the way of prudence.

J.S. Bach (1685-1750), Ach Gott und Herr, BWV 692

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Flogging made a bad man worse, and broke a good man’s heart

Mutiny on The Bounty

I answered another message about someone’s ideas about a political regime based on Old Testament law as advocated by the Reconstructionist movement.

I have just found this video which is heavy going for one who is not used to American “Reformation Christianity” language. I was able to discern the roots of these arguments from Bonface VIII’s Unam Sanctam to Pius XI’s Quas primas on Christ the King. Already, Louis Bouyer, the great French theologian, noticed half-jokingly that the Reformation essentially kept the worst of medieval Catholicism and just got rid of the beauty! Also the Anglican scholar I was shocked to recognise the reasoning of Roman Catholic traditionalists, including those who yearn for the restoration of the French Monarchy. Also in the Scriptures: “Jesus answered, My kingdom is not of this world: if my kingdom were of this world, then would my servants fight, that I should not be delivered to the Jews: but now is my kingdom not from hence. Pilate therefore said unto him, Art thou a king then? Jesus answered, Thou sayest that I am a king. To this end was I born, and for this cause came I into the world, that I should bear witness unto the truth. Every one that is of the truth heareth my voice.”

I felt unable to watch the video throughout. It was too strident for the introvert I am. The big issue seems to be reversing Original Sin and going back to Eden where man could dominate the earth. The advantage of this video, though between Restorationalists and Evangelicals (believing in the Rapture and a more Quietist / Pietist approach), is a dialectic approach to understand things better. A point was made that the Kingdom of Christ begins within each one of us and spreads out through the family, neighbourhood, city, country or state, the nation, etc. A question I ask is whether Christ-the-King-ism has ever been a reality in history.

The other question is that of freedom. Dostoievsky’s Grand Inquisitor thought it better for people not to have freedom for their own good. This is the best dramatisation I have ever seen, with John Guilgud. Boniface VIII set the tone with his Two Swords, the absolute notion of the Papacy with authority over the Temporal. Freedom is a paradox, but it is necessary so that our adhesion to God may be free and therefore “valid”. A profession of faith and repentance for heresy under torture is of no value. Only the Enlightenment could bring us out of such a nightmare, but secular humanism led to another dystopia.

This brings me to a line with some ideas in common with Rod Dreher. Our vocation as Christians is to pray for the world, but retreat to the desert (literally or metaphorically) and live the ideal as best as we can. The world has been to hell and back many times in history, and our only influence as Christians is possible with sensitive souls, not with those whose purpose of life is power, money and sexual domination.

* * *

Many utopian ideas [for example a Christian theocracy] are great whilst sitting in an armchair and dreaming about them. I live in France and have met many people who want to bring back the French Monarchy. There are two pretenders: the Count of Paris and the Duke of Anjou. How do you get them into power? Through political means? We’ll need to see how well Zemmour gets on in the next presidential elections. But, he’s not a monarchist, rather a Republican of a more nationalistic bent than the other Presidents since De Gaulle. He is also Jewish. In the same way, the problem of a theocracy in the USA will meet with a lot of resistance. It’s a dream to think what could be done, and it would be more “humane” than Islamic totalitarianism, but I don’t see it ever happening.

The other problem with any political regime, however noble the intention, is that human beings are sinners. Think of the awful Popes in Rome and elsewhere who were supposed to represent Christ – and they were no more virtuous than Mafia godfathers. As Lord Acton said, “Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely. Great men are almost always bad men, even when they exercise influence and not authority, still more when you superadd the tendency or the certainty of corruption by authority. There is no worse heresy than that the office sanctifies the holder of it.” Even the Mosaic Law cannot guarantee the authority of those whose role it would be to enforce it. That is the limit of all law. Many innocent people go to the electric chair!

Capital punishment has come up several times [in our exchanges of correspondence]. It is seen differently in America in the Republican camp than in Europe. The guillotine was used for the last time in 1977 and formally abolished in 1981. Putting people in prison for a very long time is a terrifying punishment, and they will spend many years reflecting about the futility of their lives and the heinousness of their crime (eg. murder, raping a child, etc.). The guilty will punish himself, rather than his death being loaded onto the conscience of his executioner. You should read about Robert Badinter, the French lawyer who was the most dedicated to the abolition of capital punishment. He is (he’s still alive) a brave man. Also, here in Europe, no prison sentence is without possibility of parole. For the worst, there is a “security” period of about 30 years, and then the prisoners can be evaluated case by case. That is much more human in the case of true repentance and a conversion of morals and perhaps even a spiritual self-revelation.

To anyone who wants to bring about a theocracy, I would ask him how he would bring it about. He and whose army? The only way is by a coup d’état – and that involves violence and killing. That would be wrong. That’s what the Salafist Muslims are doing. I would be more for reversing the Peace of Constantine, going back to the deserts and the catacombs (metaphorically speaking) and bringing about a different kind of Christian witness. Yes, Christians would be discriminated against and even martyred. Perhaps the Church produced its finest minds during that period of suffering under the Roman Empire. Eventually the invincible Roman Empire fell and went the way of all human pride. I believe that our greatest nobility will come from humility and discretion.

My attitude might seem to say that I don’t care for the majority of humanity. This is an important lesson that I have learned in life. We can’t change other people, only ourselves, and then try to make of our lives a witness (μαρτύριον). If we are unable to relate to the weight of godless society, then we withdraw from the city. In actual fact, many of the penal laws of the countries where we live are based on the Judeo-Christian tradition, but of course abortion is a problem. The social context of the women concerned should be taken into consideration so that they can bring the babies to term with social benefits and be allowed to offer the babies for adoption if that is their choice. Murder is punished, as are rape, fraud and theft, … The legal system in the US and our side of the pond are not perfect, and good politicians will campaign for these laws to be more Christian. That’s the best one can do to prevent anarchy and chaos.

I am not a politician, so my own duty lies elsewhere as a priest. Another principle I affirm is the primacy of faith and spiritual life over laws and morality. Morality is a consequence of faith and love, not a reaction in fear of punishment. Towards the end of the 18th century, there was an increasing awareness that sailors on a Naval ship performed better out of a team spirit and respect of the commanding officer than when they were keel-hauled and flogged. Someone in the British Admiralty at the dawn of the nineteenth century said that a flogging made a bad man worse and broke a good man’s heart. This is the essential difference between Christianity and Old Testament Judaism or Salafist Islam. There is still a law to obey, a moral ideal to follow, but its meaning is changed and interiorised.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Christian Integralism and Humanism

This talk was inspired by some correspondence with a person who is wondering about what I would call a fundamentalist and puritan Christian totalitarian theocracy.

I give a few elements of my refusal of such a system in favour of Christian Humanism, Platonism, mysticism and tolerance. Clearly the only way out of the anxiety we live through in this world is God and our spiritual life, the only way we can find knowledge, nobility of spirit, but yet a love and respect for others, even when it is impossible to understand them.

I recommend a discovery of this dimension of Christianity, of Romanticism and a way that is neither the “cancel culture” of Woke nor the pitiless legalism and hypocrisy of puritanism. God will bring us through our anxiety – if we let Him.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Archbishop John Hepworth RIP

null

Of your charity, please pray for the soul of Archbishop John Hepworth who passed away on 1st December 2021 from an illness unrelated to the present pandemic. We should not forget that he was ordained a priest in the Roman Catholic Church. He was my immediate Ordinary during my time in the TAC (Patrimony of the Primate) from 2005 to 2013.

A chapter has closed in the lives of many of us, and I will celebrate a Mass for him this coming week.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | 1 Comment